AkteureDialektikEmpirieFallanalysenInstrumenteKonzepteMetaphernPraxisanwendungenSchluesselmomenteTheoretikerTyp2WiderspruecheZis
Contradictions and Open Questions in the WA Corpus v2.8
(Datenstand: V1.2 vom August 2026)
This list documents the central contradictions, unresolved points, and open research questions identified in the WA Corpus. It is based on the question collections of Volumes 12, 14, and 18.
1. Theoretical Contradictions & Open Questions
| Question / Contradiction | Status | WB Volume | WA Documents |
|---|---|---|---|
| Are the two ZTD dimensions (structural depth and sociocognitive involvement) actually independent, or do they correlate in clinical reality? | 🔷 open | WB_18 | WAA-811 |
| How do the 16 parameters of the ZIS spider relate to one another? Are they independent or do they correlate? | 🔷 open | WB_18 | WAZ-080, WAA-820, WAA-830 |
| Can the ZTD be validated by factor-analytic or network-analytic methods? | 🔷 open | WB_18 | WAA-811 |
| How can the three levels of analysis (phenomenological, self-related, neurobiological) be methodologically linked without conflating them? | ⚪ new | WB_18 | WAA-810 |
| Can the TRASC classification (4-D model) be operationalized with the ZIS spider? | ⚪ new | WB_18 | WAA-810, WAZ-080 |
2. Methodological Contradictions & Open Questions
| Question / Contradiction | Status | WB Volume | WA Documents |
|---|---|---|---|
| Can parameter weighting be validated by empirical studies? | 🔷 open | WB_18 | WAA-880, WAA-881, WAA-885–887 |
| How do the weights behave in different disorder profiles? | 🔷 open | WB_18 | WAA-880, WAA-881 |
| How does dynamic weighting change over the course of therapy? | 🔷 open | WB_18 | WAA-880, WAA-881 |
| Can the area of the ZIS spider be correlated with other measures of dissociative complexity? | 🔷 open | WB_18 | WAZ-080, WAA-820, WAA-880 |
| What is the interrater reliability of the ZIS spider? | 🔷 open | WB_18 | WAZ-080, WAA-820 |
| How do the parameters behave over the continuous course? | 🔷 open | WB_18 | WAA-825, WAZ-080 |
| Can the item-level correction (framing, DIF, factor loadings) be empirically validated? | 🔷 open | WB_18 | WAA-887 |
3. Clinical Contradictions & Open Questions
| Question / Contradiction | Status | WB Volume | WA Documents |
|---|---|---|---|
| Can a patient change from a Type 2 placement to a Type 1 placement over the course of therapy? | 🔷 open | WB_18 | WAA-811 |
| How do Ataria, s self-dimensions behave in other Type 2 cases? | 🔷 open | WB_18 | WAA-810 |
| How can the three ZIS instruments (16-item, resources, blockade) be applied in an integrated way in clinical practice? | ⚪ new | WB_18 | WAZ-080, WAA-830 |
| What therapeutic consequences arise from the multidimensional perspective? | 🔷 open | WB_18 | WAA-810, WAA-825, WAA-880 |
| How can the companion resonance ZIS be methodologically validated when it is susceptible to self-deception? | ⚪ new | WB_08, WB_18 | WAB-22, WAA-830 |
4. Iatrogenic & Cognitive Questions (Volume 12)
| Question / Contradiction | Status | WB Volume | WA Documents |
|---|---|---|---|
| What was the actual dose of the polypharmacy? | 🔷 open | WB_12 | WAE-100 |
| Can the cognitive decline be predicted by pharmacogenetic testing? | 🔷 open | WB_12 | WAE-102 |
| What role did the mRNA injection play in the cognitive decline? | 🔷 open | WB_12 | WAE-105 |
| How can the iatrogenic addiction shift be therapeutically addressed? | 🔷 open | WB_12 | WAE-103 |
5. N Block (Type 2δ) – Questions on Necrosis
| Question / Contradiction | Status | WB Volume | WA Documents |
|---|---|---|---|
| What happens to shame when the primary consciousness permanently disappears? | 🔷 open | WB_20 | WAN-014 |
| How can Type 2δ be distinguished from Type 2 (reversible)? | 🔷 open | WB_20 | WAN-010, WAN-019 |
| Which neurobiological markers point to Type 2δ? | 🔷 open | WB_20 | WAN-011 |
| Can the lighthouse strategy still unfold an effect in Type 2δ? | 🔷 open | WB_20 | WAN-100–WAN-110 |
Statistical Overview
| Question type | Number |
|---|---|
| Theoretical contradictions & open questions | 5 |
| Methodological contradictions & open questions | 7 |
| Clinical contradictions & open questions | 5 |
| Iatrogenic & cognitive questions | 4 |
| N block (Type 2δ) – questions on necrosis | 4 |